ESG Investing in the Spotlight
July 15, 2025
People generally choose an investment with an eye toward adding financial value to their portfolio. Over the past two decades, however, many investors have added another layer of values in making investment decisions. The most common criteria are related to environmental, social, and corporate governance issues, typically referred to as ESG factors.
More recently, ESG investing has become controversial, primarily due to large institutional investors such as universities and pension funds using ESG factors to construct their portfolios. Critics say that this approach compromises potential returns, while proponents claim that better ESG practices may help lower risk and provide more stability without sacrificing performance. As an individual investor, the choice to apply personal values to your investments is entirely up to you, and it may be helpful to know more about this approach.
What’s in a name?
Values-based investing was originally called Socially Responsible Investing (SRI), and this term is still commonly used. Other terms, often using the SRI acronym, include sustainable and responsible investing; sustainable, responsible, and impact investing; or simply sustainable investing. The emphasis on ESG factors developed as a way to analyze companies in constructing funds or portfolios.
SRI and ESG are often used interchangeably, but some analysts see them as two separate practices. According to this view, SRI takes more of a pure values-based approach in screening potential investments; for example, it might screen out companies involved in fossil fuels extraction, weapons, or tobacco and screen in companies that produce “green” products or focus on financial inclusion or health.
ESG looks at these factors more in terms of risk management and financial performance; for example, a company with poor labor relations could face a workers’ strike and a company with poor waste management could be fined or constrained with government regulations.
Investments and performance
ESG strategies are often applied by professional managers for large institutional investors, but individual investors might consider these factors when developing their own portfolios. Along with screening individual stocks, investors can choose from more than 600 ESG/sustainable funds.1 As with any fund, it’s important to understand the objectives and criteria for choosing investments. Funds labeled ESG, sustainable, or socially responsible can vary widely in their objectives, in how they define and evaluate ESG factors, and in how strictly they apply selection criteria.
It’s difficult to assess the effect of ESG factors on investment performance, because there is no standard definition of what companies or investments should be included in an ESG analysis. A review of more than 1,000 research studies published from 2015–2020 reported that 33% of studies that focused on investment results found a positive correlation between ESG and performance, 26% reported a neutral impact, 28% were mixed, and just 14% found a negative correlation.2
Scored and Screened
The S&P 500 Scored and Screened Index excludes companies engaged in certain business activities (e.g., coal, weapons, tobacco) as well as other companies in the bottom 25% in each business sector based on ESG scores. Over the last decade, index performance was moderately or slightly better than the full index in seven out of 10 years.
Annual total return
2015
S&P 500 Scored & Screened Index: About 1%
S&P 500 Index: About 2%
2016
S&P 500 Scored & Screened Index: About 13%
S&P 500 Index: About 12%
2017
S&P 500 Scored & Screened Index: About 22%
S&P 500 Index: About 23%
2018
S&P 500 Scored & Screened Index: About -3%
S&P 500 Index: About -4%
2019
S&P 500 Scored & Screened Index: About 35%
S&P 500 Index: About 34%
2020
S&P 500 Scored & Screened Index: About 21%
S&P 500 Index: About 20%
2021
S&P 500 Scored & Screened Index: About 32%
S&P 500 Index: About 30%
2022
S&P 500 Scored & Screened Index: About -19%
S&P 500 Index: About -20%
2023
S&P 500 Scored & Screened Index: About 30%
S&P 500 Index: About 29%
2024
S&P 500 Scored & Screened Index: About 25%
S&P 500 Index: About 26%
Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices, 2025. The S&P 500 Index is an unmanaged group of securities considered to be representative of the U.S. stock market in general. The performance of an unmanaged index is not indicative of the performance of any specific investment. Individuals cannot invest directly in an index. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Actual results will vary. There is no assurance that employing ESG strategies will result in more favorable investment results.
Limiting the universe
Although many companies and funds consider ESG factors, focusing on these strategies limits the total universe of available investments and could make it more challenging to diversify and maintain your desired asset allocation. Like all investments, SRI/ESG stocks and funds entail risk and could lose money, and there is no guarantee that an SRI/ESG investment will achieve its objectives.
Diversification and asset allocation do not guarantee a profit or protect against loss. Funds are sold by prospectus. Please consider the investment objectives, risks, charges, and expenses carefully before investing. The prospectus, which contains this and other information about the investment company, can be obtained from your financial professional. Be sure to read the prospectus carefully before deciding whether to invest.
Sources:
1) Morningstar, February 6, 2025
2) NYU Stern Center for Sustainable Business, 2021 (most recent data)
Valuing Your Trust
If you’re not already a valued client of Providence Wealth Advisors, we encourage you to learn more. To schedule a no cost, no obligation conversation, contact us to learn more at your convenience.